Philippe the Original · Downtown, Los Angeles

Philippe's and the 100-year fight over the French dip

Two downtown restaurants spent a century claiming the French dip, and nobody had proof. In March 2026 Cole's closed for good. Two days later, Philippe's retired the sawdust it had spread across its floor for a hundred years.

Philippe the Original's corner storefront with its neon French Dipped Sandwiches sign
Photo: Bobak Ha'Eri, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

For more than a hundred years, the floor at Philippe the Original was covered in sawdust. On March 31, 2026, it wasn't. The restaurant said the decision wasn't really its own: safety and insurance standards required it. Two days earlier, across downtown, Cole's had served its last French dip.

Who dipped first

Both restaurants date themselves to 1908, and for a century both said they invented the French dip. Philippe's version, as the family tells it, starts around 1918: a roll fell into the pan drippings, and a customer in a hurry took it anyway.

Even inside the family the story moves. The founder, Philippe Mathieu, told the Los Angeles Times in 1951 that it began with a police officer asking him to split a loaf of French bread for a pork sandwich. Andrew Binder, who runs Philippe's today, has said a relative of Mathieu's later told the family it was a fireman.

Cole's had its own story, about a chef dipping a roll for a customer with sore gums. Neither restaurant ever produced a document. It was a hundred-year argument run on oral history, and in the end it was settled the way most LA arguments are: one side outlasted the other.

The Frenchman on Alameda Street

Mathieu came from France in 1901, cooked nights at the Angelus Hotel, and bought a deli on Alameda Street for $150. In 1927 he sold it to the Martin brothers, who had been renting out horses and wagons. When freeway construction took the original site, the family moved in 1951 into a former machine shop. A newspaper columnist wrote at the time that it had sawdust on the floor and cracks in the wall, and you didn't care.

Four generations later, the carvers still take your order, build the sandwich and take your money in one stop. Coffee was a nickel until 1977. It's 45 cents now. Binder has said the house mustard has a cult following, and that on a slow day they go through at least 400 to 500 pounds of beef.

A miracle, minus the sawdust

Dodger Stadium is up the hill, and Binder has said the family lives and dies by the Dodgers. So many places opened and closed around them, he told PBS SoCal, that it's a miracle they're still here. This year the miracle lost its sawdust, and its oldest rival.

If you go: get it dipped, and go easy on the mustard.

How we reported this

Your venue

Run a place with a story?

Tell us what makes it unlike anywhere else. We read every one, and the best become RollCall Stories. Nothing is published without a separate conversation.

Tell us about it