Settle it
Who killed the Red Cars?
LA's Pacific Electric Red Cars stopped in 1961. Popular memory blames a General Motors plot; most historians point to Henry Huntington's business model, fares, cars and the voters.
The end of the ride
The Pacific Electric once ran its Red Cars over about 1,100 miles of track. Route by route they gave way to buses, until the last one: Los Angeles to Long Beach, which had opened on July 4, 1902. The last Red Car ran on it in April 1961 (sources give April 8 or 9).
The trial
In 1949 a federal jury convicted General Motors, Firestone, Standard Oil of California, Phillips Petroleum and Mack Trucks of conspiring to monopolize the sale of buses and supplies to transit companies controlled by National City Lines. They were acquitted of conspiring to monopolize the transit companies themselves. GM was fined $5,000 and its treasurer, H.C. Grossman, $1. In 1974 a Senate staff attorney, Bradford Snell, revived the story, and Who Framed Roger Rabbit later turned a version of it into a cartoon villain's plan.
The car companies did it
General Motors and its partners were convicted in 1949 of conspiring to monopolize the sale of buses to the transit systems they had bought into, and the appeal failed in 1951. A National City Lines subsidiary, Pacific City Lines, bought Pacific Electric's local operations in Glendale, Burbank and Pasadena in 1940, and in 1953 the rest of the network went to another subsidiary, Metropolitan City Lines. Bradford Snell told the Senate in 1974 that GM had acted as "a sovereign economic state." Even the historian Guy Span, a critic of Snell, said GM waged a war on electric traction, while calling it "by no means the single reason."
The Red Car killed itself
99% Invisible argues the system was built mainly to sell Henry Huntington's subdivisions, not to serve the city, and fell apart as car ownership grew: "The Red Car was the conspiracy." Writing in the Daily Bruin in 1997, the UCLA planning scholar Gene Kim said the company could not raise fares as ridership fell, began swapping its weakest routes for buses about 15 years before National City Lines appeared, and declined for political, economic and social reasons. Nathan Marsak argues National City Lines "never touched one single Red Car," and that a public agency ended the system.
You decide. Each side above is its strongest case, in its own sources' words.
Timeline
- The last Red Car runs between Los Angeles and Long Beach.
- At Senate hearings, Bradford Snell's charges against GM are aired, and LA Mayor Tom Bradley testifies against the company.
In the stories
- Pacific Electric: A musician built the backstage he wished he’d found on tour.
Ben Lovett spent six years turning a Los Angeles warehouse into Pacific Electric. Some of the most revealing details are behind the stage.
Where it leads
- The Pacific Electric Railway (the Red Cars) The railway at the center of the argument 1901-1961
- Pacific Electric The music room that took the railway's name since 2026
- Formosa Cafe A bar built beside an old Red Car since 1939
How we reported this
- 99% Invisible, Episode 70: The Great Red Car Conspiracy (Jan. 11, 2013)
- Wikipedia: General Motors streetcar conspiracy
- Daily Bruin: Conspiracy theory doesn't match (Gene Kim, Apr. 28, 1997)
- Bunker Hill, Los Angeles: No, everyone, there was no Los Angeles streetcar conspiracy (Nathan Marsak, Nov. 2, 2025)
- Metro Library and Archive: This date in LA transportation history, April 8