Settle it
Who invented the Mai Tai?
Trader Vic said he invented the Mai Tai in Oakland in 1944. Donn Beach's side said Hollywood, years earlier. Ray Buhen worked for both men.
Victor Bergeron opened a beer joint in Oakland called Hinky Dinks in 1934. In 1937 he toured the bars of New Orleans, Trinidad and Havana, then visited Don the Beachcomber in Hollywood, went home and remade his place as Trader Vic's. By his account, he invented the Mai Tai there in 1944. Donn Beach's side said Donn had one first. The two recipes share little but the name. One bartender poured for both men: Ray Buhen, whose bar on Sunset still serves a Mai Tai.
Trader Vic invented it in Oakland in 1944
Bergeron's own account, still on Trader Vic's website: in 1944, at the service bar of his Oakland restaurant, he shook 17-year-old J. Wray Nephew Jamaican rum with fresh lime, Dutch orange curaçao, rock candy syrup and French orgeat, and served it to Ham and Carrie Guild, friends from Tahiti. Carrie said "Mai Tai – Roa Ae," which he translated as "Out of this World – The Best," and he named it. He later said anyone who claimed he didn't create the drink was a stinker. Jeff Berry's Total Tiki dates Donn's own Mai Tai to the 1950s, likely made to rival Vic's. Oakland named August 30 its official Mai Tai Day in 2009, and even Tiki-Ti's menu credits Vic.
Donn Beach had one first, in Hollywood
Phoebe Beach, Donn's widow, wrote in a 2001 book with Arnold Bitner that Donn invented a drink called the Mai Tai in 1933, eleven years before Vic's. Vic had been to Don the Beachcomber in 1937, before he remade his own bar in its image. A longtime colleague of Donn's said his real complaint was that Vic's Mai Tai was built on Donn's Q.B. Cooler, and some tiki historians say the two taste alike despite different ingredients. The bartender Daniel Waddy notes that Donn could have known the Tahitian word from his travels, and that Vic could have picked up the name from him.
- Punch: Don's Mai Tai (Al Culliton, August 2024)
- American Heritage: Cult tiki (Wayne Curtis, August/September 2006)
- Wikipedia: Mai Tai (history section, citing Jeff Berry's Beachbum Berry Remixed)
You decide. Each side above is its strongest case, in its own sources' words.
In the stories
- Tiki-Ti: Ray Buhen wanted customers to see who made their drinks
After years making other people’s tropical drinks, the Filipino bartender built a small bar of his own.
Where it leads
- Donn Beach One of the two claimants
- Ray Buhen Poured for both Donn Beach and Trader Vic's
- Don the Beachcomber Where Donn Beach's side says it began
- Tiki-Ti Pours a Mai Tai, and credits Trader Vic on the menu
- Who invented the French dip? Another origin fight that never got a ruling
How we reported this
- Trader Vic's: History of the Mai Tai
- American Heritage: Cult tiki (Wayne Curtis, August/September 2006)
- Punch: Don's Mai Tai (Al Culliton, August 2024)
- Wikipedia: Mai Tai (history section, citing Jeff Berry's Beachbum Berry Remixed)
- L.A. Weekly: Mike Buhen, running the show at Tiki-Ti (Besha Rodell, May 2014)
- LAist: Tiki-Ti in Los Feliz is the tiki god of bars (Danny Jensen, October 2015)
- Tiki-Ti: drink menu, 2026