Settle it

Who invented the French dip?

For a century, Philippe's and Cole's both dated themselves to 1908 and both said they invented the French dip. Cole's closed in March 2026; the argument never got a ruling.

A century, no receipts

Philippe's and Cole's both dated themselves to 1908, and for a hundred years both said the French dip was theirs. Neither restaurant ever produced a document. Tasting Table called Cole's story entirely anecdotal, passed from employee to employee, and Philippe's own website admits that why the sandwich is called French is "lost to history." It was an argument run on oral history, and it ended without a ruling: Cole's served its last French dip on March 29, 2026, and Philippe's is still carving.

The same story, twice

Each side's legend kept changing. Philippe's website says the customer was a policeman; Andrew Binder, fourth generation of the owning family, told PBS SoCal a relative of the founder's said he was a fireman. Cole's told of a chef dipping a roll in jus for a customer with sore gums. Then in 1997, Tasting Table found, Cole's then-owner told the Los Angeles Times the bread had simply fallen into the gravy, which is the Philippe's story.

Two ways to dip

The sandwiches weren't even served the same way. Philippe's dips the roll before it reaches you, and its menu offers single-dipped, double-dipped or wet. Cole's, PBS SoCal noted, served the jus in a cup on the side.

What the newspapers show

A poster on the American Dialect Society's mailing list, in a thread transcribing the story, said the paper's first mention of a "dip" or "dipped" sandwich came only in 1930. On August 27, 1951, the Times ran a story on Philippe Mathieu as the Aliso Street restaurant bearing his name closed its doors, under a headline calling him the "Man Who Made First French-Dip Sandwich."

Philippe's dipped first

Philippe's says its founder, Philippe Mathieu, dropped a sliced French roll into a pan of hot roasting juices in 1918, and the customer, a policeman, came back the next day with friends who wanted theirs dipped too. Mathieu told the Los Angeles Times his version in 1951: a police officer asked him to split one of his large loaves of French bread, and by Tasting Table's reading the first was roast pork. Binder has said a relative of the founder's told the family the customer was a fireman.

Philippe the Original

Cole's dipped first

Cole's called itself the originator of the French dip and dated its sandwich to its opening year, 1908, a decade before the date Philippe's gives for its own. As Cole's told it, a chef dipped bread in au jus for a customer whose gums were too sensitive for a crusty roll, and everyone soon wanted one. It kept telling that story through 118 years in the Pacific Electric Building, until it closed in March 2026.

Cole's French Dip

You decide. Each side above is its strongest case, in its own sources' words.

Timeline

  1. The Los Angeles Times profiles Philippe Mathieu as his Aliso Street restaurant closes, crediting him with the first French dip.
  2. Cole's serves its last French dip, ending a century-long argument without a ruling.
  3. Philippe's retires the sawdust on its floor, by its own announcement, at its insurer's request.

In the stories

Where it leads

How we reported this