Settle it

Who invented the margarita?

Tijuana, Juárez, Ensenada and a Los Angeles restaurant with a room on Ventura Boulevard all have a claim. No one has settled it.

The margarita has more birthplaces than any drink deserves. Before it there was the daisy, an early 1900s family of drinks made from a spirit, a liqueur and citrus, and margarita is Spanish for daisy. A tequila daisy shows up in American newspapers in 1936. The first known printed margarita recipe ran in Esquire in December 1953: an ounce of tequila, a dash of triple sec and half a lime or lemon. "She's from Mexico, Señores," Esquire wrote, "and she is lovely to look at, exciting and provocative."

And the rest of the field

Difford's Guide and Wikipedia list still more claims: Carlos "Danny" Herrera at Rancho La Gloria near Rosarito, for the dancer Marjorie King (a story the San Diego Reader disputed in 1992); the Dallas socialite Margaret Sames at a party in Acapulco in 1948; Santos Cruz in Galveston for Peggy Lee; and Danny Negrete in Tehuacán in 1936, for a girlfriend named Margarita.

Tijuana: a tequila daisy, maybe by mistake

The drinks historian David Wondrich's theory, as Resy retold it, is that around 1925 a Tijuana bar made a daisy with tequila instead of gin. In 1936 the Iowa newspaperman James Graham wrote about an Irish bartender in Tijuana named Madden, in what Difford's Guide counts as the first specific mention of a Tequila Daisy. A Syracuse paper advertised a Tequila Daisy that same year.

Ensenada: Hussong's Cantina, 1941

Hussong's in Ensenada also claims the margarita was created at its bar, by the bartender Don Carlos Orozco in 1941, and named for a customer, Margarita Henkel Cesena.

Los Angeles: the Tail o' the Cock

In January 1955 the Van Nuys News credited "Johnny Dresser" (Johnny Durlesser), head barman at McHenry's Tail o' the Cock restaurants, with inventing the "Marguerita" "way back in 1937." Vern Underwood of Young's Market, Cuervo's Los Angeles distributor, said of the drink, "no name had been given to it. We named it." Difford's notes the restaurant opened in 1939, but Wondrich judged Durlesser's story "unlikely to have been completely fabricated."

Tail o' the Cock

You decide. Each side above is its strongest case, in its own sources' words.

Timeline

  1. Pancho Morales later said he made the first margarita this day at Tommy's Place in Ciudad Juárez, after mishearing an order for a Magnolia.
  2. Esquire prints what Wikipedia calls the first known published margarita recipe.
  3. The Van Nuys News credits the Tail o' the Cock's head barman with inventing the "Marguerita."

In the stories

Where it leads

How we reported this