Settle it

Was Doug Weston's come-back rule fair?

To play the Troubadour, acts promised Doug Weston return engagements at their beginner's fee. He called it his share of the gold he planted. The industry rebelled and built the Roxy.

The terms

Robert Hilburn described the rule this way: for the right to play the Troubadour, an act had to guarantee Weston a series of return engagements at the same beginner's fee. WeHo Online, writing in 2013, called them loyalty contracts. Steve Martin, who signed one, remembered the paper as five weeks spread over a year or two, with Weston holding an option on the act and the pay climbing week by week, from around $250 to about $1,250. Martin was the rare act who stayed unknown long enough to enjoy the raises, and has said he couldn't believe he was making a thousand dollars a week.

What it cost him

At first, Hilburn wrote, the pop world bowed to Weston's contract provisions because the room was so powerful. Then it rebelled. In 1973 a group of industry heavyweights including Lou Adler and David Geffen opened the larger Roxy on the Sunset Strip. Weston scoffed at it. The Roxy was an instant success, the Troubadour lost its best bookings, and income sagged so badly that Weston nearly lost the club several times before taking on Ed Karayan as a partner in the early 1980s.

Fair: the club took the risk

Weston took chances on new acts, often booking them after hearing an advance copy of a debut album, and built a room where one appearance could guarantee major record sales for an emerging artist. In 1979 he said he was not Liberace waltzing to the bank: the Troubadour had been a gold mine mined by everybody else, and he wanted to mine the gold he had planted. You have to be able to minimize your risks, he liked to say, and when it came to salaries the burden of proof should rest on the artist. Even Steve Martin's version of the deal came with raises built in.

Unfair: it squeezed the talent

Hilburn, who admired Weston, wrote that he demanded what many felt were unreasonable conditions, and that his downfall as a club owner came from betraying his own principle that the artists were what mattered. In a 2009 American Masters interview, the interviewer said the people who later opened the Roxy were angry because they thought Weston was taking advantage of artists. Steve Martin believed Weston held an option on Elton John, and that Elton had to buy his way out of it once he was famous.

You decide. Each side above is its strongest case, in its own sources' words.

Timeline

  1. The Troubadour books an unknown Elton John for the week. By Classic Rock's account, Weston pays his trio $500 for eight shows.

In the stories

Where it leads

How we reported this